OpenAI’s recent controversy surrounding the perceived use of Scarlett Johansson’s voice in their AI model, ChatGPT, has stirred up debates about the future of artificial intelligence and its potential impact on creative industries and human expression. The controversy brings to light the ethical considerations and challenges that arise as AI models become increasingly advanced and capable of mimicking human voices and behaviors.
Contrary to popular belief, OpenAI denies using Johansson’s voice or having any intention to resemble it in their AI model. The organization claims that an actress was hired to create the voice of “Sky” for ChatGPT months before any contact with Johansson occurred. These claims are supported by documents, recordings, casting directors, and the actress’s agent. According to the agent, the actress has confirmed that neither Johansson nor the movie “Her” were mentioned by OpenAI during the casting process. The actress’s natural voice bears a resemblance to the AI-generated voice of Sky, based on initial voice tests.
Joanne Jang, who leads AI model behavior for OpenAI, emphasizes the meticulousness of the casting process and the agency’s commitment to preserving artistic choices. Sky’s voice was selected by OpenAI’s Chief Technology Officer, Mira Murati, in consultation with the director and casting office. Jang, who has spent numerous hours listening to the actress behind Sky’s voice, asserts that it sounds nothing like Johansson, despite sharing some qualities such as breathiness and huskiness.
OpenAI acknowledges the concerns raised by the public and the potential misperception regarding the similarity between Sky’s voice and Johansson’s. In response, they have decided to pause the use of Sky’s voice in their products out of respect for Johansson. The company issued an apology to Johansson for not communicating better during the process. Legal experts suggest that a lawsuit against OpenAI is unlikely since the company has ceased using the voice and made promises to Johansson to that effect.
The case of OpenAI and Scarlett Johansson raises broader questions about the boundaries of AI technology and its impact on various creative industries. While AI models, like ChatGPT, have the potential to enhance productivity, efficiency, and creativity, there are inherent risks. OpenAI’s consideration of using AI to generate music serves as an analogy for the ethical concerns surrounding AI’s ability to replicate human expression. Conceptually, if AI were trained on a vast collection of music created by musicians, it could learn the structure and elements of a catchy beat, but it would lack the subjective, personal touch that makes art unique and meaningful.
Sam Altman, the CEO of OpenAI, has acknowledged the dilemma of where to draw the line between human creativity and AI assistance. He draws attention to Apple’s “Crush” ad, which showcases the human creative process, as an example of the importance of preserving human input in art. Altman emphasizes that OpenAI has decided against pursuing AI-generated music, at least for now, due to the complex ethical questions it raises.
This controversy also highlights the challenges that lie ahead as AI models become more sophisticated. The line between human and AI is becoming increasingly blurred, which raises concerns about ownership, consent, and the preservation of human agency. As AI evolves, society must grapple with these ethical quandaries and establish frameworks to ensure responsible and equitable use.
Furthermore, there is a broader consideration of the impact of AI on the labor market and creative industries. With the development of AI models capable of replicating human voices and behaviors, there is a valid concern that certain jobs, such as voice actors, may be at risk of displacement. However, it is essential to recognize that AI can also present new opportunities for collaboration and innovation. For example, voice actors could work alongside AI to enhance their capabilities and create even more immersive and compelling experiences.
In conclusion, the OpenAI controversy surrounding Scarlett Johansson’s voice highlights the ethical complexities and challenges associated with AI technology. While OpenAI denies using Johansson’s voice in their AI model, the incident raises important questions about the future of AI and its impact on human expression. As AI models become more advanced, there is a need for careful consideration of the boundaries and limitations of AI’s role in creative industries. Establishing ethical frameworks and ensuring responsible use will be crucial as we navigate the evolving landscape of AI and its impact on society.
Source link
